Leading insurers undermine climate goals by supporting the tar sands industry
May 30, 2018
Heads in the sand? The insurance industry, tar sands and pipelines
Many of the world’s biggest insurers, including AIG, Munich Re and Zurich, are undermining global climate goals and Indigenous rights by supporting the tar sands industry, reveals a briefing paper by the Insure Our Future campaign released today.
NGOs supporting the campaign have also written to CEOs of the world’s largest insurance companies, meeting in Paris this week, calling on the industry to divest from coal, tar sands and associated pipeline projects and cease providing insurance cover to these climate-destroying fossil fuel projects.
- Read the full Insure Our Future briefing: Heads in the sand? The insurance industry, tar sands and pipelines
- Read the Insure Our Future letter to insurance CEOs
Peter Bosshard, coordinator of the Insure Our Future campaign, said: “New tar sands and pipeline projects lock in high carbon emissions for decades to come and are incompatible with the need to phase out fossil fuels in line with the Paris Agreement. Insurance companies should not underwrite or invest in some of the most polluting and climate-destroying projects on the planet.”
Extracting and processing tar sands in Canada’s Alberta province, which controls more than 70% of global reserves, on average creates 2.2 times more carbon emissions per barrel than other North American crude oil.The Canadian government projects that tar sands extraction in the province will grow by 77% by 2040. New tar sands mines and the associated pipelines also ravage boreal forests and watercourses, and violate Indigenous rights.
Entitled, Heads in the sand? The insurance industry, tar sands and pipelines, the briefing paper finds that under current market conditions, the proposed expansion of tar sands extraction depends on the construction of new pipelines to refineries and ports. The proposed Trans Mountain Pipeline Expansion project in Western Canada for example would transport 590,000 barrels of tar sands per day, unlocking an estimated 130 million tons of CO2 emissions per year for decades to come, violating Indigenous rights and creating massive threats to ecosystems and public health.
The briefing paper, co-published by Greenpeace US and Rainforest Action Network, names 25 insurance companies which Kinder Morgan, the developer of the Trans Mountain Pipeline Expansion project, has disclosed it has done business with in the past.
Ska-Hiish Manuel, a delegate to the Indigenous Network on Economies and Trade from the Secwepemc First Nation, whose land would be affected by the Trans Mountain pipeline, says: “Insurance companies should not insure projects which violate Indigenous rights to free, prior informed consent and undermine the Paris climate agreement. They should stay out of the Trans Mountain Pipeline Expansion project, which Indigenous claimants and their allies have challenged in the courts through 19 separate legal proceedings.”
In recent years, at least 17 major insurers have divested an estimated $23 billion from coal companies and five large insurers – including industry giants AXA and Allianz – have stopped insuring new coal projects or are about to do so citing concerns about climate change.
So far only AXA has stopped insuring tar sands and the associated pipeline projects and divested Euro 700 million from the respective companies, while Swiss Re has stopped insuring new (but not existing) tar sands projects. Major insurance companies which continue to insure coal and tar sands include Munich Re, AIG, Generali and Lloyds.
In letter to the CEOs of 25 leading global energy insurers,12 international NGOs backing the Insure Our Future campaign welcome the growing shift away from coal, but call on the industry leaders to:
- Immediately start divesting from coal, tar sands and the associated pipeline companies;
- Immediately cease insuring coal, tar sands and the associated pipeline projects and companies (unless they are engaged in a rapid transition from coal and tar sands to clean energy that would normally take no longer than two years);
- Stay away from the Trans Mountain Expansion, Keystone XL and Enbridge Line 3 tar sands pipelines in particular;
- Scale up investments in clean energy companies and insurance coverage for clean energy projects that follow international human rights, Indigenous rights, social and environmental standards.
Commenting on the letter, Lucie Pinson, European coordinator of the Insure Our Future campaign, said: “Climate science and the growing human and economic toll of climate disasters both demonstrate that we cannot afford to build any new coal and tar sands projects. Insurance CEOs need to scale up their ambitions to meet the goals of the Paris Agreement and immediately ditch these extreme fossil fuels.”
The CEOs of the 80 largest insurance companies are meeting in Paris from May 30thto June 2ndfor the annual meeting of the Geneva Association, an insurance industry think-tank. The Association Board rejected a request from the Insure Our Future campaign to meet the NGOs to discuss their concerns.
Ahead of the meeting, the Paris city council called on the world’s biggest insurers to end support for the coal industry, citing its impact on climate change and the pollution that causes nearly 23,000 premature deaths across Europe every year.
The Insure Our Future letter was signed by 350.org, the Center for International Environmental Law (USA), Divest Invest (USA), the Foundation Development Yes Open-Pit Mines No (Poland), Friends of the Earth France, numerous Greenpeace country offices, the Japan Center for a Sustainable Environment and Society, Market Forces (Australia), the Rainforest Action Network (USA), the Sunrise Project (Australia), Re:Common (Italy), and Urgewald (Germany).
Overview: coal and tar sands policies of large insurers and reinsurers (May 2018):
For further information, pictures, graphics and to arrange interviews, please contact:
Will Aitchison firstname.lastname@example.org +44 (0) 7412 872453
Rachel Parkes email@example.com +44 (0) 7775 652919
About Insure Our Future
The Insure Our Future campaign brings together a global network of NGOs and social movements calling for insurance companies to divest from and cease underwriting coal and support the transition to clean energy. The campaign is supported by 350.org, CIEL (US), ClientEarth (UK), Foundation Development YES – Open-Pit Mines NO (Poland), Friends of the Earth France, Greenpeace Switzerland, Market Forces (Australia), Rainforest Action Network (US), Re:Common (Italy), The Sunrise Project (Australia), Urgewald (Germany) and the Waterkeeper Alliance (US), among others.
Benjamin Israel, Pembina Institute, The Real GHG trend: Oilsands among the most carbon intensive crudes in North America, October 4, 2017
Greenpeace and Oil Change International, In the Pipeline: Risks for Funders of Tar Sands Pipelines, October 2017
The insurance companies are: ACE (meanwhile operating under the Chubb brand, Switzerland); AIG Cat Excess (USA); Alterra (part of Markel, USA);Amlin (Lloyd’s syndicate, meanwhile acquired by Mitsui Sumitomo, UK/Japan); ANV (Lloyd’s syndicate, part of AmTrust Group, UK/USA); Arch (UK/Bermuda); Argo (Bermuda); AXIS (Bermuda); AXIS (USA);Endurance (meanwhile acquired by Sompo, Bermuda/Japan); Great Lakes (part of Munich Re, Germany); Ironshore (meanwhile acquired by Liberty Mutual, USA); Ironstarr (Bermuda); Lancashire (UK); Lexington (part of AIG, USA); Liberty International (part of Liberty Mutual, USA); OCIL (Bermuda);O’Farrell (Lloyd’s syndicate managed by QBE, UK/Australia); SCOR (France); Starr Surplus Lines (USA); Swiss Re (Switzerland); Torus (meanwhile acquired by Enstar Group and rebranded as StarStone, UK); Westchester (meanwhile acquired by Chubb, USA/Switzerland); XL Insurance (meanwhile under acquisition by AXA, Bermuda/France); and Zurich (Switzerland).
The letter was addressed at the CEOs of AIG (USA), Allianz (Germany), Aviva (UK), Axis Capital (USA), AXA (France), W.R. Berkley (USA), Berkshire Hathaway (USA), Chubb (Switzerland), Generali (Italy), Hannover Re (Germany), Legal & General (UK), Liberty Mutual (USA), Lloyd’s (UK), Mapfre (Spain), MetLife (USA), Munich Re (Germany), Prudential (USA), QBE (Australia), SCOR (France), Sompo (Japan), Swiss Re (Switzerland), TIAA (USA), Tokio Marine (Japan), XL Group (Bermuda), and Zurich (Switzerland). These companies overlap with but are not identical with the companies which have in the past insured Kinder Morgan.
The Insure Our Future campaign defines coal companies as companies which depend on coal for more than 30% of their business, produce at least 20 million tons of coal per year, or operate at least 10 GW of coal power stations. It defines tar sands companies as companies which hold at least 20% of their oil reserves in tar sands. The campaign will tighten these definitions over time.